Preparing a trial balance sounds straightforward — but did you know there are actually three different methods to do it? Each method serves a specific purpose, and knowing the differences between them is a common exam question in CBSE Class 11 Accountancy. In this guide, you will learn all three methods step by step, with a single worked example applied across all three — exactly the way NCERT presents it in Chapter 6.

Why Does the Method of Preparation Matter?

All three methods of preparing a trial balance are based on the same core data from the ledger. The difference lies in what is recorded in the trial balance — totals, balances, or both — and how useful each format is for decision-making and financial statement preparation.

Method 1: Totals Method

In the Totals Method, the total of each side (debit and credit) of every ledger account is calculated separately and entered into the trial balance. This means the trial balance shows gross totals, not net balances.

How it works:

  • Calculate the total of all entries on the debit side of each ledger account.

  • Calculate the total of all entries on the credit side of each ledger account.

  • Enter both in their respective columns of the trial balance.

  • The total of the debit column should equal the total of the credit column (since every transaction has equal debit and credit).

Limitation: This method is not widely used in practice because it does not reflect the net balance of individual accounts, making it harder to prepare financial statements or assess the financial position.

Method 2: Balances Method

The Balances Method is the most commonly used method in practice. Instead of showing gross totals, it shows the net closing balance of each ledger account — either a debit balance or a credit balance.

How it works:

  • Balance each ledger account by finding the difference between its debit and credit sides.

  • List each account and enter the closing balance in the appropriate debit or credit column.

  • Total both columns — they should agree.

Why it is preferred:

  • Account balances reflect the net effect of all transactions for that account.

  • It directly supports the preparation of the Balance Sheet and Profit & Loss Account.

  • It is cleaner and more compact than the Totals Method.

In this method, the trial balance shows only one figure per account — the net balance. Sundry debtors and sundry creditors are shown as aggregates rather than individual accounts.

Method 3: Totals-cum-Balances Method

The Totals-cum-Balances Method is a combination of both methods above. It requires four columns for amounts:

  1. Debit Totals

  2. Credit Totals

  3. Debit Balances

  4. Credit Balances

This gives a complete picture of both the gross activity in each account and its net standing.

Limitation: Although comprehensive, this method is rarely used in practice because it is time-consuming and the additional detail it provides does not serve any special purpose beyond what the Balances Method already offers.

Solved Example – All Three Methods Applied

Let us apply all three methods using Mr. Rawat’s accounts (adapted from NCERT Chapter 6). The key balances and totals extracted from his ledger are:

AccountDebit Total (₹)Credit Total (₹)Debit Balance (₹)Credit Balance (₹)
Rawat's Capital—60,000—60,000
Rohan (Creditor)40,00060,000—20,000
Machinery20,0003,00017,000—
Rahul (Debtor)75,00055,00020,000—
Sales—70,000—70,000
Cash1,00,00057,00043,000—
Wages5,000—5,000—
Depreciation3,000—3,000—
Purchases62,000—62,000—
Total3,05,0003,05,0001,50,0001,50,000

Using the Totals Method:

Both debit total column and credit total column sum to ₹3,05,000. ✓

Using the Balances Method:

Both debit balance column and credit balance column sum to ₹1,50,000. ✓

Using the Totals-cum-Balances Method:

All four columns agree — debit totals = credit totals = ₹3,05,000, and debit balances = credit balances = ₹1,50,000. ✓

Key Differences at a Glance

FeatureTotals MethodBalances MethodTotals-cum-Balances
What is shownGross totalsNet balancesBoth
Used in practiceRarelyMost commonlyRarely
Useful for final accountsNoYesYes (but complex)
Number of amount columns224

Common Exam Tips

  • The Balances Method is always asked in board exams and should be your default approach.

  • Remember: accounts with zero balance may still be shown in the trial balance with a zero in their normal balance column.

  • The fact that a trial balance tallies does not mean there are no errors — it only confirms arithmetical accuracy.

Start Practising Chapter 6 Questions Today

Understanding theory is only half the battle — you need practice to ace your boards. ChampionsPrep offers chapter-wise MCQs, long-answer practice sets, and instant doubt resolution for Class XI Commerce students.

📚 Head to app.championsprep.in to try our Trial Balance question bank with PrepCoin packs from ₹59.

3 Methods to Prepare a Trial Balance – With Solved Example | Class 11 Accountancy podcast artwork
Audio LessonClass 11

3 Methods to Prepare a Trial Balance – With Solved Example | Class 11 Accountancy

ChampionsPrep AccountancyEpisode 512:24

Subscribe in any podcast app:

Frequently Asked Questions

Which method of preparing a trial balance is most widely used? +

The Balances Method is the most widely used in practice because it shows the net effect of all transactions and directly aids in preparing financial statements.

Why is the Totals Method not preferred? +

The Totals Method shows gross debits and credits rather than net balances, making it difficult to assess the actual financial position and prepare final accounts.

Can a trial balance tally even when there are errors? +

Yes. Errors of complete omission, errors of principle, and compensating errors do not affect the agreement of the trial balance.

What is the Totals-cum-Balances Method? +

It is a combination of the Totals and Balances methods, requiring four amount columns. It is rarely used in practice because it is time-consuming with little additional benefit.

What happens if the trial balance does not tally? +

It signals that at least one error has occurred. The accountant must investigate posting, balancing, and transfer stages to locate and correct the error.